Download these free Flubby the Cat finger puppets. Print them on card stock and color to make your own kitty characters. I taped a pipe cleaner tail to the backside of mine. If you are making a class sized batch, a 5/8" hole punch from the craft store works great for cutting out the finger holes.
And don't forget to read these purr-fectly fun easy reader books, FLUBBY IS NOT A GOOD PET! and FLUBBY WILL NOT PLAY WITH THAT!